"
through your window pane,
I'm creeping closer,
Can you hear me?
Go on, mock me, say I'm insane;
But it's you who's caught in my game.
Cat and mouse,
A lovely circle.
Watch your tongue,
Those words are hurtful.
Hush now, won't you stay a while?
Join me with a painted smile.
Madame Macarbre explains us how Jeff arrives to the house of it's victims: "
climbing through your window pane", she also tells that Jeff arrives very quietly to his victims to surprise them: he says "
Can you hear me?", it's ironic, because he is killing at night, when everyone is asleep and he doesn't make noise, so no one will hear him.
"
Go on, mock me, say I'm insane" may be what his victims are saying, but it is a well a warning like,"Just try to say that, you will see what will happen", it's reinforced by the following line "
But it's you who's caught in my game".
He enjoys killing and hurting people (as you know if you read the story), he takes this just like a game "
Cat and Mouse", like this innocent game when the Mouse has to escape the Cat, and that's what he thinks, that's it's "
A Lovely Circle" because he knows that he will catch them after all.
"
Watch your tongue,Those words are huntful": Jeff was bullied before he went crazy, so the insults of insanity or anything approaching hurts him deep within and he gets even more violent.
"
Join me with a painted smile" literally means that he add his "signature" to the body of his victims by craving them a jocker smile on their faces, just like the one he made to himself.